Abstarct: Axiomatic design technique is a scientific and systematic approach in system design ,that accept of scientists and researcher in various scientific fields. The acceptance technique arising from using the independence axiom and information axiom in design so that has been created meaning different with other design technique . but the most important challenge for manager is “how select to best design from system with different design baxsed on AD” . knowledge and experience designer in the use of principle has led to create the plan with different efficiency and utility. Selection Optimum design baxsed on independence and information axiom and new indicator that introduced in this paper is called comprehensive principle. This thesis aims to propose a frxamework for the evaluation of the validity of plan baxsed on two complementary techniques developed in the context of multiple criteria decision analysis. The MACBETH technique is used to define numerical values baxsed on verbal statements. It is complemented by the silent negotiation technique which is a heuristic technique used for the purpose of reaching a consensus within a group of people. To reach a consensus decision on the opinions of 20 people in 5 projection, and three criteria are used. Result is shown the Macbeth technique have better validity than other MCDM technique . because Macbeth is humanistic , interactive , constructive and analyzing judgment inconsistence and offering suggestions to move the process forward.